Something that particularly bugs me about the governing bodies of various sports is when they decide to make a change to a certain facet of the rules or system that there is seemingly no problem with. These changes are often unpopular with the fan base, making them seem pointless, especially when time and thought could be better invested into aspects that perhaps do need fixing.
One of these instances was in V8 Supercars. A few years back the general qualifying system was a certain time period where all cars were allowed to go out and post the fastest lap they could, followed by a "Top 10 Shootout" which was very exciting and everyone loved it. However a couple of years ago they decided to oust this system and implement an F1 style structure that was much less popular. Unsurprisingly, the shootout made it's return this season.
Another instance of this in V8s was a change this year which sees a qualifying session before every race, where previously the grid for races after race 1 on a weekend would be decided by the finishing order of the previous race. Nobody had a problem with the system while this new procedure seems to have disadvantages such as good battles that occurred in race 1 being unable to continue due to the drivers being separated by a new grid.
A big example is about to hit us in cricket. After being trialled in a number of Test Matches, the 'referral' system will become apart of the game later this year. Cricket umpires are quite good and are considered to make the correct decision at least 90% of the time. There have been no great outcries over umpiring in cricket, it is one of the smoothest officiating systems out of all sports. So why unnecessarily introduce challenges? Especially after the trial was far from flawless. I witnessed a number of decisions reversed by the 3rd Umpire due to a challenge that left me scratching my head.
And I couldn't go without having a dig at the NRL in this article. Golden Point. Why the hell was this introduced? When two teams are equal at the end of a contest, the fair result is a draw, one point each yes? But no, the NRL decided to bring in a way to artificially get a winner.
Honestly, I could bring up numerous rules changes or "new interpretations" that the NRL have come up with that have been inappropriate, the grounding of the ball for a try for one while actual issues go unpoliced such as playing the ball with your foot and walking off the mark.
The message is quite simple, don't change a good thing. Its one way to frustrate the fans and turn them against you.
Showing posts with label Rules. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rules. Show all posts
Sunday, May 31, 2009
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
The Most Ridiculous Rule in the NRL
It is rarely needed, but the most ludicrous rule in the NRL rule book has reared its ugly head in the same game two years in a row. If the ball hits a referee, he is deemed to have interfered with play and a scrum shall be packed with the feed going to the team who is in attack, which is determined by which half the ball is in.
In last years heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the Tigers were on the attack with the score 10-6 in favour of Souths who were searching for their first win of the season. The Bunnies managed to defend well and on a 4th tackle play, the ball was grubbered straight into referee Ben Cummins. Rabbitohs fans were disgusted when a scrum was awarded to the Tigers, who got another full set and scored. They hit the lead and from there the whole complexion of the game had changed. In a tight, perhaps crucial point in the game, the Tigers were handed an unfair advantage and there was nothing the Rabbits could do from preventing this turning point.
Coincidentally, last weekend in the heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the same event happened. The Tigers had just made in into the "attacking half" when on the last play, Farrah planted his kick right into referee Ashley Klein. A Tigers scrum feed followed as the Souths fans chant of "Bull$h*t" rang throughout the ground. Luckily for Souths the Tigers did not managed to score off the back of it, and the rest of that game is history.
It is amazing that such an archaic, unfair rule still exists in the game. The defending team is penalised for doing nothing wrong, for something they have no control over. You could even argue that they pay for a mistake made by the opposition. The NRL need to change this rule now, although it very rarely happens there is a chance it could occur in a big game, an Origin or a Grand Final, and unfairly change the course of that game.
There are many fairer options the NRL could consider when changing the rule. A simple turnover could be ruled, the same as when a team makes a mistake on the last play, the team could be told to go back and play the ball again or a scrum or play the ball could be awarded to kicking team but the tackle count does not restart.
Is it possible that players could start aiming at the ref more often as an option to get a repeat set? Effectively a player could turn around, chase the ref patrolling the ruck and kick the ball into them to get a scrum feed.
The NRL has enough unclear or unpopular rules, simple anomalies like this should be eliminated. All it does is unnecessarily add to the problem.
Below are the two incidents.
In last years heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the Tigers were on the attack with the score 10-6 in favour of Souths who were searching for their first win of the season. The Bunnies managed to defend well and on a 4th tackle play, the ball was grubbered straight into referee Ben Cummins. Rabbitohs fans were disgusted when a scrum was awarded to the Tigers, who got another full set and scored. They hit the lead and from there the whole complexion of the game had changed. In a tight, perhaps crucial point in the game, the Tigers were handed an unfair advantage and there was nothing the Rabbits could do from preventing this turning point.
Coincidentally, last weekend in the heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the same event happened. The Tigers had just made in into the "attacking half" when on the last play, Farrah planted his kick right into referee Ashley Klein. A Tigers scrum feed followed as the Souths fans chant of "Bull$h*t" rang throughout the ground. Luckily for Souths the Tigers did not managed to score off the back of it, and the rest of that game is history.
It is amazing that such an archaic, unfair rule still exists in the game. The defending team is penalised for doing nothing wrong, for something they have no control over. You could even argue that they pay for a mistake made by the opposition. The NRL need to change this rule now, although it very rarely happens there is a chance it could occur in a big game, an Origin or a Grand Final, and unfairly change the course of that game.
There are many fairer options the NRL could consider when changing the rule. A simple turnover could be ruled, the same as when a team makes a mistake on the last play, the team could be told to go back and play the ball again or a scrum or play the ball could be awarded to kicking team but the tackle count does not restart.
Is it possible that players could start aiming at the ref more often as an option to get a repeat set? Effectively a player could turn around, chase the ref patrolling the ruck and kick the ball into them to get a scrum feed.
The NRL has enough unclear or unpopular rules, simple anomalies like this should be eliminated. All it does is unnecessarily add to the problem.
Below are the two incidents.
Labels:
Heritage Round,
Kick,
NRL,
Rabbitohs,
Rugby League,
Rules,
SCG,
South Sydney,
Souths,
TC Ink,
Tigers,
Wests Tigers
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)