The NRL have released their annual State of the Game document for 2009. The document contains information on crowds, ratings, refereeing and much more for the 09 season. Why it is released before the end of the regular season is beyond me, but I'm sure they have their reasons...
For those who would like the read the whole think, click here.
For those who don't, I will pick out the interesting parts and report.
The summary page picks out the best bits. An impressive stat is that this years comp will set the highest attendance record except for when there were 20 teams. This along with the fact that average crowds are up by 2.12% on last year are a testament to the work clubs and the NRL has done in driving membership numbers (which rose by a massive 27% to about 110 000), promoting games as well as special events for certain days for example family fun day. This is all a step in the right direction.
Overall, channel 9 ratings have increased. It is a bit hard to take any facts out of this as the accuracy of ratings are questionable, but I suppose the increase in viewers is a good sign.
Similar to last year, NRL has 60 of the top 100 rating shows on Pay TV.
One of the most encouraging points for me, was that club player registrations rose by 6.8% from last year to take it to an all time high. A new junior participation record of 124 319 was set. This is great news for the future of the game as it shows that grassroots are stable.
The NRL donated nearly $2 million to charity this season.
The top 3 clubs with the greatest increase in average crowds were the Bulldogs, up 45%, the Warriors, up 36%, and the Panthers, up 26%. The Bulldogs are in fact sitting 2nd behind the Broncos is average crowds, which is a great effort. I imagine that they are the first Sydney team to finish with an average of over 20 000 for a long time. The Tigers broke their home ground record against the Eels at the SFS (34 272) and so did the Bulldogs against the Warriors last weekend (41 835), which was also the highest crowd for a stand alone regular season game in Sydney in 35 years.
The is a 'research' section, which displays some strange figures. I don't know how they got these figures, I suppose a survey went around at some point. But apparently supporter's passion has increased from 5.9 out of 1o to 6.5. Seems like a bit of a gimmick to me. It also says that 36% of people interested in League attended a game, up from 27% last year. That is a positive sign and one that needs to keep increasing. The Toyota Cup is also growing in popularity. Also in this section is says that fans seem to think that:
-Game play is improving.
-Off field behaviour has gotten worse (Surprise, surprise).
-They are more likely to attend games.
Here are some stats that I found quite interesting. In '08 340 tries were scored from kicks. This is down to 272 in '09 (with 1 round remaining). Dummy half runs have also dropped. This could be due to the 2 ref system, it is good never the less. Total penalties have also slightly dropped, video ref decision have also had a significant decrease.
So there you have it, some interesting information there from the 2009 State of the Game document. It seems as though the game is strengthening and I can only see things improving once again next season.
Showing posts with label Rugby League. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Rugby League. Show all posts
Friday, September 4, 2009
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
Covell for Covell Award
The man that inspired the creation of this award has finally booked himself a nomination. Luke Covell decided to send this easy kick from just to the side of the posts wide, sacrificing a lead for Cronulla. Just for fun, I added in another similar miss that occurred at the end of the game. Superb effort Mr Covell, a goal kicker of your quality should come up with this brilliance more often!
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
Hazem El Masri,
NRL,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Sunday, June 14, 2009
Even the Best Can Covell
Another Covell Award nominee has been a while coming but it has finally arrived. He was probably the least expected candidate, being the best goal kicker in the world, but even the best have their moments of Covell madness. Hazem El Masri "duffed" this kick on Friday night to the shock of all on lookers. Perhaps he was just keen to be in with a chance at the award?
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
Hazem El Masri,
NRL,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Sunday, May 31, 2009
If It Ain't Broke, Don't Fix it
Something that particularly bugs me about the governing bodies of various sports is when they decide to make a change to a certain facet of the rules or system that there is seemingly no problem with. These changes are often unpopular with the fan base, making them seem pointless, especially when time and thought could be better invested into aspects that perhaps do need fixing.
One of these instances was in V8 Supercars. A few years back the general qualifying system was a certain time period where all cars were allowed to go out and post the fastest lap they could, followed by a "Top 10 Shootout" which was very exciting and everyone loved it. However a couple of years ago they decided to oust this system and implement an F1 style structure that was much less popular. Unsurprisingly, the shootout made it's return this season.
Another instance of this in V8s was a change this year which sees a qualifying session before every race, where previously the grid for races after race 1 on a weekend would be decided by the finishing order of the previous race. Nobody had a problem with the system while this new procedure seems to have disadvantages such as good battles that occurred in race 1 being unable to continue due to the drivers being separated by a new grid.
A big example is about to hit us in cricket. After being trialled in a number of Test Matches, the 'referral' system will become apart of the game later this year. Cricket umpires are quite good and are considered to make the correct decision at least 90% of the time. There have been no great outcries over umpiring in cricket, it is one of the smoothest officiating systems out of all sports. So why unnecessarily introduce challenges? Especially after the trial was far from flawless. I witnessed a number of decisions reversed by the 3rd Umpire due to a challenge that left me scratching my head.
And I couldn't go without having a dig at the NRL in this article. Golden Point. Why the hell was this introduced? When two teams are equal at the end of a contest, the fair result is a draw, one point each yes? But no, the NRL decided to bring in a way to artificially get a winner.
Honestly, I could bring up numerous rules changes or "new interpretations" that the NRL have come up with that have been inappropriate, the grounding of the ball for a try for one while actual issues go unpoliced such as playing the ball with your foot and walking off the mark.
The message is quite simple, don't change a good thing. Its one way to frustrate the fans and turn them against you.
One of these instances was in V8 Supercars. A few years back the general qualifying system was a certain time period where all cars were allowed to go out and post the fastest lap they could, followed by a "Top 10 Shootout" which was very exciting and everyone loved it. However a couple of years ago they decided to oust this system and implement an F1 style structure that was much less popular. Unsurprisingly, the shootout made it's return this season.
Another instance of this in V8s was a change this year which sees a qualifying session before every race, where previously the grid for races after race 1 on a weekend would be decided by the finishing order of the previous race. Nobody had a problem with the system while this new procedure seems to have disadvantages such as good battles that occurred in race 1 being unable to continue due to the drivers being separated by a new grid.
A big example is about to hit us in cricket. After being trialled in a number of Test Matches, the 'referral' system will become apart of the game later this year. Cricket umpires are quite good and are considered to make the correct decision at least 90% of the time. There have been no great outcries over umpiring in cricket, it is one of the smoothest officiating systems out of all sports. So why unnecessarily introduce challenges? Especially after the trial was far from flawless. I witnessed a number of decisions reversed by the 3rd Umpire due to a challenge that left me scratching my head.
And I couldn't go without having a dig at the NRL in this article. Golden Point. Why the hell was this introduced? When two teams are equal at the end of a contest, the fair result is a draw, one point each yes? But no, the NRL decided to bring in a way to artificially get a winner.
Honestly, I could bring up numerous rules changes or "new interpretations" that the NRL have come up with that have been inappropriate, the grounding of the ball for a try for one while actual issues go unpoliced such as playing the ball with your foot and walking off the mark.
The message is quite simple, don't change a good thing. Its one way to frustrate the fans and turn them against you.
Labels:
Cricket,
Referrals,
Rugby League,
Rule Changes,
Rules,
TC Ink,
V8 Supercars,
V8s
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
TC's Ratings (NRL)
In my opinion anyway, this season is shaping up as one of the most interesting ever. Whoever ends up winning this competition is going to have to work extremely hard. This is simply because there are so many premiership chances. There are teams like the Bulldogs who have flown out of the blocks and top the competition and there are also those such as Manly who have stumbled early but are slowly creeping their way back.
Lets take a look at how I currently rate the 16 teams.
1. Bulldogs
You can't pick any team ahead of them at the moment. They officially lost to the Dragons, but really, they beat them. Perhaps swap this loss with the game they should have lost, but ended up winning (of course, the 14 man incident, losing them 2 points) against the Panthers. Their other loss, which is more concerning, was against the Titans - without Scott Prince. This shows there are weaknesses for the team and could easily encounter a rough patch soon, but they will be there come finals.
2. Dragons
Just beat the competition leaders, but should have lost. If not for their loss against the Cowboys, however, I would have rated them as number 1. Wayne Bennett has taken no time to get this team performing and come finals they will take a lot of stopping.
3. Panthers
Penrith have easily been the surprise of 2009. Sitting in 4th on the table when everybody expected them to challenge for the spoon. They have plenty of young players coming of age as well as a wealth of experience in players such as Luke Lewis and Civoniceva. They have what it takes to give the comp a shake. It is a real shame that they play the Dragons this week. Both sides will be without some of their big players and no indication of where both sides are at should be taken out of it.
4. Knights
The Knights have looked a well structured, well coached outfit. They just need to iron out their inconsistency. They will also be a big player come finals. The Knights are another team facing a big opponent this week, comp leaders Bulldogs. Another game ruined by Origin absentees.
5. Storm
As we go down, it gets harder for me to separate these teams. The Storm haven't been the amazing force of recent years but they are still a very, very good side. Losing comfortably to the Dogs on the weekend was a big blow and Origin may also hurt them. But they will 'Storm' home in the latter stages of the season and are certainly an outside chance at the title.
6. Sea Eagles
Don't forget the premiers. They are by no means out of it yet. After a horror start to the season, on and off the field, they are slowly creeping back up the table. They will probably rack up some good wins over the next month or so and shoot themselves into the 8. If Brett Stewart returns later in the season, they just may be able to find that Premiership winning form at the right time.
7. Broncos
It was a tough decision to slide the Broncos all the way down here. But I honestly think they are lucky to be third on the table at the moment. They have had a relatively easy draw and have not been outstanding in most of those games. The origin period will hurt them. The Broncos are not a chance for Grand Final 09.
8. Titans
The final couple of top 8 spots will be hotly contested and I have no idea who will jag the final spot. I'm going to say the Titans sit here currently, they have looked on and off throughout the season. I would be not at all surprised if they have another 2nd half of season downturn and end up missing the 8. They have beaten some big teams, but something just doesn't seem right to me. In saying that, they have a relatively easy draw...
9. Cowboys
North Queensland have had a funny season. They started off shockingly, winning 1 from their first 5. After putting away the Sharks and Manly, they seemed to be gathering steam - only to go down to the lowly Eels. From there they then knocked off the Dragons and then yesterday the Knights. Perhaps a finals team, but they have a pretty hard draw and will do well to make it.
10. Rabbitohs
Would the real South Sydney please stand up? They look a great team but they are just not performing. They should have dealt with the Eels easily, but Parramatta outplayed them. They got close to the leaders the Bulldogs, they got close to the Titans and they beat the Knights. They definitely have something there and they need to find "it" soon (consistently), otherwise they will miss out.
11. Tigers
Another team with potential. The Tigers have turned in some good performances and had some back luck, losing their last 3 games by 2 points or less. They have some tough games approaching and will be hard pressed making the finals. However with Benji at his best, anything could happen...
12. Raiders
Canberra will be disapointed with their teams performance. After such an exciting finish to last year they came out in 09 really flat and now they are a very outside chance at making the finals. Campese the key.
13. Eels
No improvement from the Eels this year. Hayne at fullback is their shining light. They are going to remain low for the remainder of the season.
14. Warriors
What happened to the Warriors. They looked a top 8 certainty pre-season. They are playing crap at present but they could turn it around. The next few games could spell the end for the Warriors.
15. Roosters
It won't be long before the Roosters drop below the Sharks I feel. Fittler is messing around with the team and his incompetence is showing as he feels the pinch. Bye bye Fittler, bye bye Roosters 09.
16. Sharks
Turmoil. No money, no sponsors, no wins. Off field drama and an under performing team. What a fall, they were marked by many as a strong chance for the premiership in the beginning. Now all they can do is try and salvage some pride and they do have the potential to do a bit of that.
Lets take a look at how I currently rate the 16 teams.
1. Bulldogs
You can't pick any team ahead of them at the moment. They officially lost to the Dragons, but really, they beat them. Perhaps swap this loss with the game they should have lost, but ended up winning (of course, the 14 man incident, losing them 2 points) against the Panthers. Their other loss, which is more concerning, was against the Titans - without Scott Prince. This shows there are weaknesses for the team and could easily encounter a rough patch soon, but they will be there come finals.
2. Dragons
Just beat the competition leaders, but should have lost. If not for their loss against the Cowboys, however, I would have rated them as number 1. Wayne Bennett has taken no time to get this team performing and come finals they will take a lot of stopping.
3. Panthers
Penrith have easily been the surprise of 2009. Sitting in 4th on the table when everybody expected them to challenge for the spoon. They have plenty of young players coming of age as well as a wealth of experience in players such as Luke Lewis and Civoniceva. They have what it takes to give the comp a shake. It is a real shame that they play the Dragons this week. Both sides will be without some of their big players and no indication of where both sides are at should be taken out of it.
4. Knights
The Knights have looked a well structured, well coached outfit. They just need to iron out their inconsistency. They will also be a big player come finals. The Knights are another team facing a big opponent this week, comp leaders Bulldogs. Another game ruined by Origin absentees.
5. Storm
As we go down, it gets harder for me to separate these teams. The Storm haven't been the amazing force of recent years but they are still a very, very good side. Losing comfortably to the Dogs on the weekend was a big blow and Origin may also hurt them. But they will 'Storm' home in the latter stages of the season and are certainly an outside chance at the title.
6. Sea Eagles
Don't forget the premiers. They are by no means out of it yet. After a horror start to the season, on and off the field, they are slowly creeping back up the table. They will probably rack up some good wins over the next month or so and shoot themselves into the 8. If Brett Stewart returns later in the season, they just may be able to find that Premiership winning form at the right time.
7. Broncos
It was a tough decision to slide the Broncos all the way down here. But I honestly think they are lucky to be third on the table at the moment. They have had a relatively easy draw and have not been outstanding in most of those games. The origin period will hurt them. The Broncos are not a chance for Grand Final 09.
8. Titans
The final couple of top 8 spots will be hotly contested and I have no idea who will jag the final spot. I'm going to say the Titans sit here currently, they have looked on and off throughout the season. I would be not at all surprised if they have another 2nd half of season downturn and end up missing the 8. They have beaten some big teams, but something just doesn't seem right to me. In saying that, they have a relatively easy draw...
9. Cowboys
North Queensland have had a funny season. They started off shockingly, winning 1 from their first 5. After putting away the Sharks and Manly, they seemed to be gathering steam - only to go down to the lowly Eels. From there they then knocked off the Dragons and then yesterday the Knights. Perhaps a finals team, but they have a pretty hard draw and will do well to make it.
10. Rabbitohs
Would the real South Sydney please stand up? They look a great team but they are just not performing. They should have dealt with the Eels easily, but Parramatta outplayed them. They got close to the leaders the Bulldogs, they got close to the Titans and they beat the Knights. They definitely have something there and they need to find "it" soon (consistently), otherwise they will miss out.
11. Tigers
Another team with potential. The Tigers have turned in some good performances and had some back luck, losing their last 3 games by 2 points or less. They have some tough games approaching and will be hard pressed making the finals. However with Benji at his best, anything could happen...
12. Raiders
Canberra will be disapointed with their teams performance. After such an exciting finish to last year they came out in 09 really flat and now they are a very outside chance at making the finals. Campese the key.
13. Eels
No improvement from the Eels this year. Hayne at fullback is their shining light. They are going to remain low for the remainder of the season.
14. Warriors
What happened to the Warriors. They looked a top 8 certainty pre-season. They are playing crap at present but they could turn it around. The next few games could spell the end for the Warriors.
15. Roosters
It won't be long before the Roosters drop below the Sharks I feel. Fittler is messing around with the team and his incompetence is showing as he feels the pinch. Bye bye Fittler, bye bye Roosters 09.
16. Sharks
Turmoil. No money, no sponsors, no wins. Off field drama and an under performing team. What a fall, they were marked by many as a strong chance for the premiership in the beginning. Now all they can do is try and salvage some pride and they do have the potential to do a bit of that.
Labels:
Form,
NRL,
Predictions,
Premiership,
Rankings,
Ratings,
Rugby League,
TC Ink
Monday, May 25, 2009
Challenges the Way to go for NRL
Something must be done quickly to stop the rot that is NRL refereeing at the moment. Good games are being ruined and unfairly decided by poor officiating. Fans hate it, players hate it, coaches hate it, clubs hate it, punters hate it: it is making our game look like a farce.
The latest edition in the recent series of unfortunate events was a penalty against Manly half back Matt Orford after he dived on a loose ball kicked through by Preston Campbell. He was ruled to have taken Campbell out, even though he was clearly contesting the ball and even landed on top of the footy. Many people have been left bewildered, wondering what referee Matt Cecchin could have possibly seen to make his decision. Even with two referees, two touch judges and one video referee an incorrect game defining decision was made. Inexperience? A bad mistake? Whatever the reason, it is now clear that we cannot fix up the officiating in our game by adding more refs, neither can we magically improve the quality of our refs.
Last year the NRL got it wrong when they introduced video ref checking on nearly every knock on or penalty. It dramatically slowed the game down and they often made wrong decisions anyway.
There is a simple solution that has not yet been discussed as an option for Rugby League and it is one that has been introduced into other sports with success. The challenge system could resolve the issues we are currently encountering. It has worked in tennis, is (controversially) about to be introduced into cricket and has been a part of NFL for years. The NRL need to look at this option quickly and introduce a good system.
To prevent many stoppages and a challenge on every call, they should be made scarce, perhaps two incorrect challenges for each team in the game and then they get no more. That way they would only be used for obvious mistakes or crucial decisions. The captain must notify the ref of a challenge immediately. And if the video ref cannot definitely say that the ref has made a mistake after two looks, the decision stands.
A challenge system with these rules could really clean up the mistakes made by refs in the game and would also not slow the game down too much. If the NRL decides on a challenge system they must get it right.
As for video ref mistakes, Gus Gould has made a good point many times, that there should be an ex player in the box aiding with decisions.
The latest edition in the recent series of unfortunate events was a penalty against Manly half back Matt Orford after he dived on a loose ball kicked through by Preston Campbell. He was ruled to have taken Campbell out, even though he was clearly contesting the ball and even landed on top of the footy. Many people have been left bewildered, wondering what referee Matt Cecchin could have possibly seen to make his decision. Even with two referees, two touch judges and one video referee an incorrect game defining decision was made. Inexperience? A bad mistake? Whatever the reason, it is now clear that we cannot fix up the officiating in our game by adding more refs, neither can we magically improve the quality of our refs.
Last year the NRL got it wrong when they introduced video ref checking on nearly every knock on or penalty. It dramatically slowed the game down and they often made wrong decisions anyway.
There is a simple solution that has not yet been discussed as an option for Rugby League and it is one that has been introduced into other sports with success. The challenge system could resolve the issues we are currently encountering. It has worked in tennis, is (controversially) about to be introduced into cricket and has been a part of NFL for years. The NRL need to look at this option quickly and introduce a good system.
To prevent many stoppages and a challenge on every call, they should be made scarce, perhaps two incorrect challenges for each team in the game and then they get no more. That way they would only be used for obvious mistakes or crucial decisions. The captain must notify the ref of a challenge immediately. And if the video ref cannot definitely say that the ref has made a mistake after two looks, the decision stands.
A challenge system with these rules could really clean up the mistakes made by refs in the game and would also not slow the game down too much. If the NRL decides on a challenge system they must get it right.
As for video ref mistakes, Gus Gould has made a good point many times, that there should be an ex player in the box aiding with decisions.
Labels:
Challenge System,
Challenges,
Footy,
NRL,
Ref Mistakes,
Referee,
Refereeing,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Tuesday, May 19, 2009
The Most Ridiculous Rule in the NRL
It is rarely needed, but the most ludicrous rule in the NRL rule book has reared its ugly head in the same game two years in a row. If the ball hits a referee, he is deemed to have interfered with play and a scrum shall be packed with the feed going to the team who is in attack, which is determined by which half the ball is in.
In last years heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the Tigers were on the attack with the score 10-6 in favour of Souths who were searching for their first win of the season. The Bunnies managed to defend well and on a 4th tackle play, the ball was grubbered straight into referee Ben Cummins. Rabbitohs fans were disgusted when a scrum was awarded to the Tigers, who got another full set and scored. They hit the lead and from there the whole complexion of the game had changed. In a tight, perhaps crucial point in the game, the Tigers were handed an unfair advantage and there was nothing the Rabbits could do from preventing this turning point.
Coincidentally, last weekend in the heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the same event happened. The Tigers had just made in into the "attacking half" when on the last play, Farrah planted his kick right into referee Ashley Klein. A Tigers scrum feed followed as the Souths fans chant of "Bull$h*t" rang throughout the ground. Luckily for Souths the Tigers did not managed to score off the back of it, and the rest of that game is history.
It is amazing that such an archaic, unfair rule still exists in the game. The defending team is penalised for doing nothing wrong, for something they have no control over. You could even argue that they pay for a mistake made by the opposition. The NRL need to change this rule now, although it very rarely happens there is a chance it could occur in a big game, an Origin or a Grand Final, and unfairly change the course of that game.
There are many fairer options the NRL could consider when changing the rule. A simple turnover could be ruled, the same as when a team makes a mistake on the last play, the team could be told to go back and play the ball again or a scrum or play the ball could be awarded to kicking team but the tackle count does not restart.
Is it possible that players could start aiming at the ref more often as an option to get a repeat set? Effectively a player could turn around, chase the ref patrolling the ruck and kick the ball into them to get a scrum feed.
The NRL has enough unclear or unpopular rules, simple anomalies like this should be eliminated. All it does is unnecessarily add to the problem.
Below are the two incidents.
In last years heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the Tigers were on the attack with the score 10-6 in favour of Souths who were searching for their first win of the season. The Bunnies managed to defend well and on a 4th tackle play, the ball was grubbered straight into referee Ben Cummins. Rabbitohs fans were disgusted when a scrum was awarded to the Tigers, who got another full set and scored. They hit the lead and from there the whole complexion of the game had changed. In a tight, perhaps crucial point in the game, the Tigers were handed an unfair advantage and there was nothing the Rabbits could do from preventing this turning point.
Coincidentally, last weekend in the heritage round match between the Wests Tigers and the South Sydney Rabbitohs at the SCG, the same event happened. The Tigers had just made in into the "attacking half" when on the last play, Farrah planted his kick right into referee Ashley Klein. A Tigers scrum feed followed as the Souths fans chant of "Bull$h*t" rang throughout the ground. Luckily for Souths the Tigers did not managed to score off the back of it, and the rest of that game is history.
It is amazing that such an archaic, unfair rule still exists in the game. The defending team is penalised for doing nothing wrong, for something they have no control over. You could even argue that they pay for a mistake made by the opposition. The NRL need to change this rule now, although it very rarely happens there is a chance it could occur in a big game, an Origin or a Grand Final, and unfairly change the course of that game.
There are many fairer options the NRL could consider when changing the rule. A simple turnover could be ruled, the same as when a team makes a mistake on the last play, the team could be told to go back and play the ball again or a scrum or play the ball could be awarded to kicking team but the tackle count does not restart.
Is it possible that players could start aiming at the ref more often as an option to get a repeat set? Effectively a player could turn around, chase the ref patrolling the ruck and kick the ball into them to get a scrum feed.
The NRL has enough unclear or unpopular rules, simple anomalies like this should be eliminated. All it does is unnecessarily add to the problem.
Below are the two incidents.
Labels:
Heritage Round,
Kick,
NRL,
Rabbitohs,
Rugby League,
Rules,
SCG,
South Sydney,
Souths,
TC Ink,
Tigers,
Wests Tigers
Monday, May 11, 2009
Wallace Earns Covell Award Nomination
We have ourselves another new name on the list of Covell award nominations. Peter Wallace sent this kick from the sideline to "Bathurst" (Thanks Vossy!). He is our first nominee from a rep game, this coming from the City Country match on Friday night. At the time, this was to tie up the game.
It looks like Benji Marshall's effort from the last batch will not make the final cut of potential award winners at the end of the season.
It looks like Benji Marshall's effort from the last batch will not make the final cut of potential award winners at the end of the season.
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
NRL,
Peter Wallace,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink,
Wallace
Thursday, April 30, 2009
Gallen Let off After NRL Judiciary Farce
Cronulla Sharks lock Paul Gallen has escaped his one match ban after successfully pleading not guilty for a grade 1 careless high tackle.
Gallen was charged after he clearly hit Craig Wing high with a stiff, swinging arm last Friday night. The tackle forced Wing off the field where he spent half an hour recovering from a dizzy state before retaking the field. The incident did not even get penalised during the game, a ridiculous miss by two referees who have lately been intent on finding anything to penalise. The high shot was referred to the judiciary after the game.
After the Sharks learnt that Gallen faced a one match suspension, and that if they fought the charge and lost that there would be no further penalty, they of course decided to plead not guilty. Most logical people thought this decision pointless as they saw the tackle as a more than legitimate offense to be charged and in fact didn't worry to much about just presuming that Gallen would be suspended. But they let him off.
Reportedly Ricky Stuart delivered a passionate plea to the judiciary which was aided by him giving a physical demonstration of the tackle on Gallen himself. He explained how his arm bounced off his chest, and contact with the head was unavoidable. What a load of rubbish, look at the image below and tell yourself honestly that there wasn't large contact with Wings chin. What are the judiciary doing, watching Ricky or watching the tape?

Ricky also stated "He did not react as though 'I'm stuffed here'... There was no reaction". OK Ricky, so if Gallen went onto the field with a knife and lopped somebodies leg off and then looked one hundred percent innocent afterwards, he should be let off right? He couldn't have done it.
The Sharks skipper is a common face around the judiciary and is well known as an aggressive and particular dirty player, particularly after it was revealed a while ago that he ripped out the stitches from beneath an opposing players bandage during a tackle. Now they have let him off for a blatant high tackle, what is this showing to him and other players? This is not going to help Gallen clean up these blemishes in his game.
Last Sunday on the Footy Show, Mark Geyer remarked that the incident had only been sighted because of his reputation. Wrong. Incidents like this build his reputation.
Players have conducted tackles much more harmless than this in the past and have been suspended for it. Perhaps the panel just felt sorry for the hapless Sharks or perhaps they pitied Ricky after he was blasted by Phil Gould in the paper. Whatever the reason, they have gone mad.
The boys over at the judiciary have set a new precedent: its open slather on high tackles this week in the NRL! Go get 'em fellas!
Gallen was charged after he clearly hit Craig Wing high with a stiff, swinging arm last Friday night. The tackle forced Wing off the field where he spent half an hour recovering from a dizzy state before retaking the field. The incident did not even get penalised during the game, a ridiculous miss by two referees who have lately been intent on finding anything to penalise. The high shot was referred to the judiciary after the game.
After the Sharks learnt that Gallen faced a one match suspension, and that if they fought the charge and lost that there would be no further penalty, they of course decided to plead not guilty. Most logical people thought this decision pointless as they saw the tackle as a more than legitimate offense to be charged and in fact didn't worry to much about just presuming that Gallen would be suspended. But they let him off.
Reportedly Ricky Stuart delivered a passionate plea to the judiciary which was aided by him giving a physical demonstration of the tackle on Gallen himself. He explained how his arm bounced off his chest, and contact with the head was unavoidable. What a load of rubbish, look at the image below and tell yourself honestly that there wasn't large contact with Wings chin. What are the judiciary doing, watching Ricky or watching the tape?

Ricky also stated "He did not react as though 'I'm stuffed here'... There was no reaction". OK Ricky, so if Gallen went onto the field with a knife and lopped somebodies leg off and then looked one hundred percent innocent afterwards, he should be let off right? He couldn't have done it.
The Sharks skipper is a common face around the judiciary and is well known as an aggressive and particular dirty player, particularly after it was revealed a while ago that he ripped out the stitches from beneath an opposing players bandage during a tackle. Now they have let him off for a blatant high tackle, what is this showing to him and other players? This is not going to help Gallen clean up these blemishes in his game.
Last Sunday on the Footy Show, Mark Geyer remarked that the incident had only been sighted because of his reputation. Wrong. Incidents like this build his reputation.
Players have conducted tackles much more harmless than this in the past and have been suspended for it. Perhaps the panel just felt sorry for the hapless Sharks or perhaps they pitied Ricky after he was blasted by Phil Gould in the paper. Whatever the reason, they have gone mad.
The boys over at the judiciary have set a new precedent: its open slather on high tackles this week in the NRL! Go get 'em fellas!
Labels:
Cronulla,
Gallen,
High Tackle,
Judiciary,
Not Guilty,
NRL,
Paul Gallen,
Ricky Stuart,
Rugby League,
Sharks,
Suspension,
TC Ink
Wednesday, April 29, 2009
Covell Award Special: Round 7
After a long dry spell, the Covell Award is back in full force! 5 of our goal kickers decided to entertain us last weekend with spectacular misses.
First off, on Friday night Rabbitohs halfback Chris Sandow got the ball rolling with this poor attempt from the sideline.
In hindsight this kick probably isn't even that bad after seeing some of what is still to come!
From the sideline again, this time is was Cameron Smith's turn to butcher a kick. He completes an amazing feat as he manages stuff up his goal kick so bad that the ball makes it all the way from one sideline to the other.
Isn't it great how the commentators talk him up before he kicks it?! In the same game, we move to extra time. Our first field goal attempt is added to the collection. Stacey Jones' addition is extra special: he was right in front, had plenty of time and... It would have won them the game!!!
A man with one leg could have knocked that one over! To Sunday, and a relatively new name in the league stuffed up this goal kick from nearly right in front.
Well done Josh Dugan. And finally our last edition for this massive weekend. Benji Marshall, who was instrumental in the Tigers comeback victory over the Knights, also managed to get himself a nomination. Take note of the great build up commentary by our friend Gus Gould.
Damnit Benji!
Anyway, that completes our collection from Round 7. In the end we think we may have chosen too many, so if you believe that any of those kicks aren't good (or bad) enough to be a final nomination, then you can cast a vote for that kick to be excluded in the poll located in the right column at the top (Go to the blog homepage if you are viewed this as a feed). Hopefully you can help us out there.
That wraps up last weekend horrible kicking showcase. We hope you enjoyed this special presentation of the Covell award and heres to there being more stuff ups in the weeks to come!
First off, on Friday night Rabbitohs halfback Chris Sandow got the ball rolling with this poor attempt from the sideline.
In hindsight this kick probably isn't even that bad after seeing some of what is still to come!
From the sideline again, this time is was Cameron Smith's turn to butcher a kick. He completes an amazing feat as he manages stuff up his goal kick so bad that the ball makes it all the way from one sideline to the other.
Isn't it great how the commentators talk him up before he kicks it?! In the same game, we move to extra time. Our first field goal attempt is added to the collection. Stacey Jones' addition is extra special: he was right in front, had plenty of time and... It would have won them the game!!!
A man with one leg could have knocked that one over! To Sunday, and a relatively new name in the league stuffed up this goal kick from nearly right in front.
Well done Josh Dugan. And finally our last edition for this massive weekend. Benji Marshall, who was instrumental in the Tigers comeback victory over the Knights, also managed to get himself a nomination. Take note of the great build up commentary by our friend Gus Gould.
Damnit Benji!
Anyway, that completes our collection from Round 7. In the end we think we may have chosen too many, so if you believe that any of those kicks aren't good (or bad) enough to be a final nomination, then you can cast a vote for that kick to be excluded in the poll located in the right column at the top (Go to the blog homepage if you are viewed this as a feed). Hopefully you can help us out there.
That wraps up last weekend horrible kicking showcase. We hope you enjoyed this special presentation of the Covell award and heres to there being more stuff ups in the weeks to come!
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
NRL,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Tuesday, April 28, 2009
Footy Theory Rounds 7-8
After a dismal showing from the theory in round 7, it hopes to bounce back in round 8. The theory stated last week that Broncos and the Bulldogs would lose or at least struggle. Well, that didn't exactly happen. In fact the Broncos delivered another crushing defeat, 40-8 over Parramatta.
Next week the Broncos come up against the Knights, in Newcastle. The Knights have been looking good lately and will be looking to bounce back after giving up a big lead against the Tigers last weekend. The Broncos have been in hot form and surely they are about to burn out, well that's what the theory says.
Another form team, the Dragons, flogged that Roosters 29-0 on Anzac Day. The Dragons are at home at Win Stadium to the Warriors this week and it is shaping up to be a cracker of a game. The Warriors squandered opportunities to win their game against the Storm last week in extra time, which ended in a 14 all draw, and will be looking to make up for it. The theory says the Dragons wont be convincing in this game, but it looks like it will be very close and could go either way.
I'm also going to class the Panthers win over the Titans as a big win. They travel to Canberra who put up a decent showing against the Dogs last weekend. Some may say that the Raiders are due for a victory and that the Panthers are due for a loss so the theory might be in business here.
So in summary TC's Footy Theory for this week says:
- Knights over the Broncos
- Warriors over the Dragons
- Raiders over the Panthers
Coming soon on TC Ink: The Covell award. We are still sifting through the many bad kicks and preparing the special presentation!
Next week the Broncos come up against the Knights, in Newcastle. The Knights have been looking good lately and will be looking to bounce back after giving up a big lead against the Tigers last weekend. The Broncos have been in hot form and surely they are about to burn out, well that's what the theory says.
Another form team, the Dragons, flogged that Roosters 29-0 on Anzac Day. The Dragons are at home at Win Stadium to the Warriors this week and it is shaping up to be a cracker of a game. The Warriors squandered opportunities to win their game against the Storm last week in extra time, which ended in a 14 all draw, and will be looking to make up for it. The theory says the Dragons wont be convincing in this game, but it looks like it will be very close and could go either way.
I'm also going to class the Panthers win over the Titans as a big win. They travel to Canberra who put up a decent showing against the Dogs last weekend. Some may say that the Raiders are due for a victory and that the Panthers are due for a loss so the theory might be in business here.
So in summary TC's Footy Theory for this week says:
- Knights over the Broncos
- Warriors over the Dragons
- Raiders over the Panthers
Coming soon on TC Ink: The Covell award. We are still sifting through the many bad kicks and preparing the special presentation!
Labels:
Footy,
NRL,
Rugby League,
TC Ink,
Theory
Sunday, April 26, 2009
Coming up on TC Ink...
We have a packed out lineup for this week after an eventful round of footy amongst other things.
TC will be launching a personal blog, more of a journal in which he will track his much anticipated tour of England with Collaroy Plateau Cricket Club. He will cover all the build up events as he prepares to make his mark on the other side of the world.
The Covell award is back with a very special edition. This weekend provided us with plenty of disgraceful kicking efforts, we have a lot to cover and there is still one game to go!
We take a look at failings of our Footy Theory.
And after all that if we still have time, some referee analysis/discussion could be thrown in, because... well there has been some dodgy stuff going on lately. We'll also talk some cricket and perhaps F1.
Stay tuned!
TC will be launching a personal blog, more of a journal in which he will track his much anticipated tour of England with Collaroy Plateau Cricket Club. He will cover all the build up events as he prepares to make his mark on the other side of the world.
The Covell award is back with a very special edition. This weekend provided us with plenty of disgraceful kicking efforts, we have a lot to cover and there is still one game to go!
We take a look at failings of our Footy Theory.
And after all that if we still have time, some referee analysis/discussion could be thrown in, because... well there has been some dodgy stuff going on lately. We'll also talk some cricket and perhaps F1.
Stay tuned!
Labels:
Coming Up,
Covell Award,
Cricket,
Footy,
NRL,
Rugby League,
TC Ink,
Theory,
Tour Blog
Wednesday, April 22, 2009
TC's Footy Theory: Round 6-7
No, we haven't gone and hidden this under a rock because it was a total flop. In fact, if you look at the first installment and then check the results, you will find that TC's Footy Theory delivered some predictive genius. Since then there has been some close scores, so there wasn't really a need to push the theory on inapplicable results.
Anyway, round 6 saw a return to comprehensive victories. We'll drag out the theory and see how it goes for round 7. First off last Friday night the Broncos ran in a 20 point victory over the Panthers. This weekend Brisbane come up against the more-than-struggling Eels. To be honest, the theory is going to be standing on shaky ground for this game, in fact it probably would be wise to just forget it. Tipping the Eels to win in Brisbane would be far too risky. Lets move on.
This coming round the Cowboys are up against a resurgent Sea Eagles side. Now, the Cowboys had a big win last round - as did the Eagles. The big wins cancel each other out, and means the theory does not apply here. However, despite the loss of Brett Stewart, the Eagles are looking good for this game.
Finally, the Bulldogs belted the Eels 48-18 on Sunday. The Dogs come up against the hot and cold Raiders this Sunday, in Canberra. The theory says the Dogs will struggle in this game. They are due for a off game and the Raiders have looked good over the past couple of weeks. This is a potential special for the theory. Perhaps the bookies have stolen the theory, that would explain why they have installed the high flying Bulldogs as underdogs in the game!
Anyway, round 6 saw a return to comprehensive victories. We'll drag out the theory and see how it goes for round 7. First off last Friday night the Broncos ran in a 20 point victory over the Panthers. This weekend Brisbane come up against the more-than-struggling Eels. To be honest, the theory is going to be standing on shaky ground for this game, in fact it probably would be wise to just forget it. Tipping the Eels to win in Brisbane would be far too risky. Lets move on.
This coming round the Cowboys are up against a resurgent Sea Eagles side. Now, the Cowboys had a big win last round - as did the Eagles. The big wins cancel each other out, and means the theory does not apply here. However, despite the loss of Brett Stewart, the Eagles are looking good for this game.
Finally, the Bulldogs belted the Eels 48-18 on Sunday. The Dogs come up against the hot and cold Raiders this Sunday, in Canberra. The theory says the Dogs will struggle in this game. They are due for a off game and the Raiders have looked good over the past couple of weeks. This is a potential special for the theory. Perhaps the bookies have stolen the theory, that would explain why they have installed the high flying Bulldogs as underdogs in the game!
Labels:
Footy,
NRL,
Predictions,
Rugby League,
TC Ink,
Theory
Thursday, April 9, 2009
Lyon to be Forced to Stand up for Origin
Manly centre Jamie Lyon has failed in an application to be exempt from playing representative football, meaning that if he gets selected for the New South Wales Blues, he must play for the New South Wales Blues - or be stood down from Manly.
What right do the NRL have to decide this? It seems a bit rough, to be forcing someone into representative football, if they would just prefer to focus on their club. It's ridiculous that the NRL can do this, in fact, it seems a breach of freedom, or something along those lines, to actually force a player to play Origin.
On the other hand, what is Lyon thinking? Who would turn down an opportunity to play in the biggest Rugby League clashes of all? It is understandable for older players to hang up the Origin boots, if they feel they are just not up to the toughness of the series anymore. But Lyon still has years left in him and is still playing great football - after playing seven origin games in the past, why give it up now? His state may need him for that centre position, Lyon is state of origin material. He is letting the Blues down. Could you imagine Mitchell Johnson refusing to be picked for Australia? Playing for New South Wales is what kids dream about, some players would give anything to play it, but Lyon wants to give it away at 27.
But now that this has all unfolded, would the selectors be insane enough to pick him? He has declared his clear intentions of not wanting to play origin, surely the selectors wont pick a player who wont want to be on the field. It could have a terrible influence and effect on the rest of the team. If the bloke doesn't want to be there, then don't pick him, let him have it his way. Pick another player who would be dieing for the spot and would give their all.
Let Lyon put his full concentration into the bottom placed team.
What right do the NRL have to decide this? It seems a bit rough, to be forcing someone into representative football, if they would just prefer to focus on their club. It's ridiculous that the NRL can do this, in fact, it seems a breach of freedom, or something along those lines, to actually force a player to play Origin.
On the other hand, what is Lyon thinking? Who would turn down an opportunity to play in the biggest Rugby League clashes of all? It is understandable for older players to hang up the Origin boots, if they feel they are just not up to the toughness of the series anymore. But Lyon still has years left in him and is still playing great football - after playing seven origin games in the past, why give it up now? His state may need him for that centre position, Lyon is state of origin material. He is letting the Blues down. Could you imagine Mitchell Johnson refusing to be picked for Australia? Playing for New South Wales is what kids dream about, some players would give anything to play it, but Lyon wants to give it away at 27.
But now that this has all unfolded, would the selectors be insane enough to pick him? He has declared his clear intentions of not wanting to play origin, surely the selectors wont pick a player who wont want to be on the field. It could have a terrible influence and effect on the rest of the team. If the bloke doesn't want to be there, then don't pick him, let him have it his way. Pick another player who would be dieing for the spot and would give their all.
Let Lyon put his full concentration into the bottom placed team.
Labels:
Jamie Lyon,
Lyon,
Origin,
Rugby League,
State,
State of Origin,
TC Ink
Wednesday, April 8, 2009
Thats Gould
We can't have footy players stuffing up goal kicks every week, so it's about time we added a new little segment here to TC Ink. And it will be giving due recognition to a commentator we either love, or love to hate.
While many people out there can't stand Phil Gould, I personally enjoy listening to his commentary, comments and ideas. He has a fantastic footy brain and can often read situations in games perfectly, giving viewers a good insight into the game. Gus is also not afraid to speak his mind on issues he has with the game of rugby league, such as News Limited ownership and dodgy rules, despite working for channel 9.
Unfortunately for Gus, he doesn't think before he talks and often comes out with rediculous statements that are stupid and wrong. He also can't admit when he's wrong.
But beside all this, Gus entertains us week in week out with expert, extravagant commentary which, basically, can be just plain funny. His trademarks include "No no no no no" and "Dear oh dear oh dear". Anyway this segment is a tribute to Gus Gould's corkers in commentary, we present to you: Thats Gould!
Watch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3f3Dj5W4zgM
While many people out there can't stand Phil Gould, I personally enjoy listening to his commentary, comments and ideas. He has a fantastic footy brain and can often read situations in games perfectly, giving viewers a good insight into the game. Gus is also not afraid to speak his mind on issues he has with the game of rugby league, such as News Limited ownership and dodgy rules, despite working for channel 9.
Unfortunately for Gus, he doesn't think before he talks and often comes out with rediculous statements that are stupid and wrong. He also can't admit when he's wrong.
But beside all this, Gus entertains us week in week out with expert, extravagant commentary which, basically, can be just plain funny. His trademarks include "No no no no no" and "Dear oh dear oh dear". Anyway this segment is a tribute to Gus Gould's corkers in commentary, we present to you: Thats Gould!
Watch: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3f3Dj5W4zgM
Labels:
Footy,
NRL,
Phil Gould,
Rugby League,
TC Ink
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)