Showing posts with label Refereeing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Refereeing. Show all posts

Friday, September 4, 2009

NRL State of the Game Document 2009

The NRL have released their annual State of the Game document for 2009. The document contains information on crowds, ratings, refereeing and much more for the 09 season. Why it is released before the end of the regular season is beyond me, but I'm sure they have their reasons...

For those who would like the read the whole think, click here.

For those who don't, I will pick out the interesting parts and report.

The summary page picks out the best bits. An impressive stat is that this years comp will set the highest attendance record except for when there were 20 teams. This along with the fact that average crowds are up by 2.12% on last year are a testament to the work clubs and the NRL has done in driving membership numbers (which rose by a massive 27% to about 110 000), promoting games as well as special events for certain days for example family fun day. This is all a step in the right direction.

Overall, channel 9 ratings have increased. It is a bit hard to take any facts out of this as the accuracy of ratings are questionable, but I suppose the increase in viewers is a good sign.

Similar to last year, NRL has 60 of the top 100 rating shows on Pay TV.

One of the most encouraging points for me, was that club player registrations rose by 6.8% from last year to take it to an all time high. A new junior participation record of 124 319 was set. This is great news for the future of the game as it shows that grassroots are stable.

The NRL donated nearly $2 million to charity this season.

The top 3 clubs with the greatest increase in average crowds were the Bulldogs, up 45%, the Warriors, up 36%, and the Panthers, up 26%. The Bulldogs are in fact sitting 2nd behind the Broncos is average crowds, which is a great effort. I imagine that they are the first Sydney team to finish with an average of over 20 000 for a long time. The Tigers broke their home ground record against the Eels at the SFS (34 272) and so did the Bulldogs against the Warriors last weekend (41 835), which was also the highest crowd for a stand alone regular season game in Sydney in 35 years.

The is a 'research' section, which displays some strange figures. I don't know how they got these figures, I suppose a survey went around at some point. But apparently supporter's passion has increased from 5.9 out of 1o to 6.5. Seems like a bit of a gimmick to me. It also says that 36% of people interested in League attended a game, up from 27% last year. That is a positive sign and one that needs to keep increasing. The Toyota Cup is also growing in popularity. Also in this section is says that fans seem to think that:
-Game play is improving.
-Off field behaviour has gotten worse (Surprise, surprise).
-They are more likely to attend games.

Here are some stats that I found quite interesting. In '08 340 tries were scored from kicks. This is down to 272 in '09 (with 1 round remaining). Dummy half runs have also dropped. This could be due to the 2 ref system, it is good never the less. Total penalties have also slightly dropped, video ref decision have also had a significant decrease.

So there you have it, some interesting information there from the 2009 State of the Game document. It seems as though the game is strengthening and I can only see things improving once again next season.

Monday, May 25, 2009

Challenges the Way to go for NRL

Something must be done quickly to stop the rot that is NRL refereeing at the moment. Good games are being ruined and unfairly decided by poor officiating. Fans hate it, players hate it, coaches hate it, clubs hate it, punters hate it: it is making our game look like a farce.

The latest edition in the recent series of unfortunate events was a penalty against Manly half back Matt Orford after he dived on a loose ball kicked through by Preston Campbell. He was ruled to have taken Campbell out, even though he was clearly contesting the ball and even landed on top of the footy. Many people have been left bewildered, wondering what referee Matt Cecchin could have possibly seen to make his decision. Even with two referees, two touch judges and one video referee an incorrect game defining decision was made. Inexperience? A bad mistake? Whatever the reason, it is now clear that we cannot fix up the officiating in our game by adding more refs, neither can we magically improve the quality of our refs.

Last year the NRL got it wrong when they introduced video ref checking on nearly every knock on or penalty. It dramatically slowed the game down and they often made wrong decisions anyway.

There is a simple solution that has not yet been discussed as an option for Rugby League and it is one that has been introduced into other sports with success. The challenge system could resolve the issues we are currently encountering. It has worked in tennis, is (controversially) about to be introduced into cricket and has been a part of NFL for years. The NRL need to look at this option quickly and introduce a good system.

To prevent many stoppages and a challenge on every call, they should be made scarce, perhaps two incorrect challenges for each team in the game and then they get no more. That way they would only be used for obvious mistakes or crucial decisions. The captain must notify the ref of a challenge immediately. And if the video ref cannot definitely say that the ref has made a mistake after two looks, the decision stands.

A challenge system with these rules could really clean up the mistakes made by refs in the game and would also not slow the game down too much. If the NRL decides on a challenge system they must get it right.

As for video ref mistakes, Gus Gould has made a good point many times, that there should be an ex player in the box aiding with decisions.