The man that inspired the creation of this award has finally booked himself a nomination. Luke Covell decided to send this easy kick from just to the side of the posts wide, sacrificing a lead for Cronulla. Just for fun, I added in another similar miss that occurred at the end of the game. Superb effort Mr Covell, a goal kicker of your quality should come up with this brilliance more often!
Showing posts with label Sport. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sport. Show all posts
Wednesday, June 17, 2009
Covell for Covell Award
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
Hazem El Masri,
NRL,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Sunday, June 14, 2009
Even the Best Can Covell
Another Covell Award nominee has been a while coming but it has finally arrived. He was probably the least expected candidate, being the best goal kicker in the world, but even the best have their moments of Covell madness. Hazem El Masri "duffed" this kick on Friday night to the shock of all on lookers. Perhaps he was just keen to be in with a chance at the award?
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
Hazem El Masri,
NRL,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Monday, May 25, 2009
Challenges the Way to go for NRL
Something must be done quickly to stop the rot that is NRL refereeing at the moment. Good games are being ruined and unfairly decided by poor officiating. Fans hate it, players hate it, coaches hate it, clubs hate it, punters hate it: it is making our game look like a farce.
The latest edition in the recent series of unfortunate events was a penalty against Manly half back Matt Orford after he dived on a loose ball kicked through by Preston Campbell. He was ruled to have taken Campbell out, even though he was clearly contesting the ball and even landed on top of the footy. Many people have been left bewildered, wondering what referee Matt Cecchin could have possibly seen to make his decision. Even with two referees, two touch judges and one video referee an incorrect game defining decision was made. Inexperience? A bad mistake? Whatever the reason, it is now clear that we cannot fix up the officiating in our game by adding more refs, neither can we magically improve the quality of our refs.
Last year the NRL got it wrong when they introduced video ref checking on nearly every knock on or penalty. It dramatically slowed the game down and they often made wrong decisions anyway.
There is a simple solution that has not yet been discussed as an option for Rugby League and it is one that has been introduced into other sports with success. The challenge system could resolve the issues we are currently encountering. It has worked in tennis, is (controversially) about to be introduced into cricket and has been a part of NFL for years. The NRL need to look at this option quickly and introduce a good system.
To prevent many stoppages and a challenge on every call, they should be made scarce, perhaps two incorrect challenges for each team in the game and then they get no more. That way they would only be used for obvious mistakes or crucial decisions. The captain must notify the ref of a challenge immediately. And if the video ref cannot definitely say that the ref has made a mistake after two looks, the decision stands.
A challenge system with these rules could really clean up the mistakes made by refs in the game and would also not slow the game down too much. If the NRL decides on a challenge system they must get it right.
As for video ref mistakes, Gus Gould has made a good point many times, that there should be an ex player in the box aiding with decisions.
The latest edition in the recent series of unfortunate events was a penalty against Manly half back Matt Orford after he dived on a loose ball kicked through by Preston Campbell. He was ruled to have taken Campbell out, even though he was clearly contesting the ball and even landed on top of the footy. Many people have been left bewildered, wondering what referee Matt Cecchin could have possibly seen to make his decision. Even with two referees, two touch judges and one video referee an incorrect game defining decision was made. Inexperience? A bad mistake? Whatever the reason, it is now clear that we cannot fix up the officiating in our game by adding more refs, neither can we magically improve the quality of our refs.
Last year the NRL got it wrong when they introduced video ref checking on nearly every knock on or penalty. It dramatically slowed the game down and they often made wrong decisions anyway.
There is a simple solution that has not yet been discussed as an option for Rugby League and it is one that has been introduced into other sports with success. The challenge system could resolve the issues we are currently encountering. It has worked in tennis, is (controversially) about to be introduced into cricket and has been a part of NFL for years. The NRL need to look at this option quickly and introduce a good system.
To prevent many stoppages and a challenge on every call, they should be made scarce, perhaps two incorrect challenges for each team in the game and then they get no more. That way they would only be used for obvious mistakes or crucial decisions. The captain must notify the ref of a challenge immediately. And if the video ref cannot definitely say that the ref has made a mistake after two looks, the decision stands.
A challenge system with these rules could really clean up the mistakes made by refs in the game and would also not slow the game down too much. If the NRL decides on a challenge system they must get it right.
As for video ref mistakes, Gus Gould has made a good point many times, that there should be an ex player in the box aiding with decisions.
Labels:
Challenge System,
Challenges,
Footy,
NRL,
Ref Mistakes,
Referee,
Refereeing,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Monday, May 11, 2009
Wallace Earns Covell Award Nomination
We have ourselves another new name on the list of Covell award nominations. Peter Wallace sent this kick from the sideline to "Bathurst" (Thanks Vossy!). He is our first nominee from a rep game, this coming from the City Country match on Friday night. At the time, this was to tie up the game.
It looks like Benji Marshall's effort from the last batch will not make the final cut of potential award winners at the end of the season.
It looks like Benji Marshall's effort from the last batch will not make the final cut of potential award winners at the end of the season.
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
NRL,
Peter Wallace,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink,
Wallace
Wednesday, April 29, 2009
Covell Award Special: Round 7
After a long dry spell, the Covell Award is back in full force! 5 of our goal kickers decided to entertain us last weekend with spectacular misses.
First off, on Friday night Rabbitohs halfback Chris Sandow got the ball rolling with this poor attempt from the sideline.
In hindsight this kick probably isn't even that bad after seeing some of what is still to come!
From the sideline again, this time is was Cameron Smith's turn to butcher a kick. He completes an amazing feat as he manages stuff up his goal kick so bad that the ball makes it all the way from one sideline to the other.
Isn't it great how the commentators talk him up before he kicks it?! In the same game, we move to extra time. Our first field goal attempt is added to the collection. Stacey Jones' addition is extra special: he was right in front, had plenty of time and... It would have won them the game!!!
A man with one leg could have knocked that one over! To Sunday, and a relatively new name in the league stuffed up this goal kick from nearly right in front.
Well done Josh Dugan. And finally our last edition for this massive weekend. Benji Marshall, who was instrumental in the Tigers comeback victory over the Knights, also managed to get himself a nomination. Take note of the great build up commentary by our friend Gus Gould.
Damnit Benji!
Anyway, that completes our collection from Round 7. In the end we think we may have chosen too many, so if you believe that any of those kicks aren't good (or bad) enough to be a final nomination, then you can cast a vote for that kick to be excluded in the poll located in the right column at the top (Go to the blog homepage if you are viewed this as a feed). Hopefully you can help us out there.
That wraps up last weekend horrible kicking showcase. We hope you enjoyed this special presentation of the Covell award and heres to there being more stuff ups in the weeks to come!
First off, on Friday night Rabbitohs halfback Chris Sandow got the ball rolling with this poor attempt from the sideline.
In hindsight this kick probably isn't even that bad after seeing some of what is still to come!
From the sideline again, this time is was Cameron Smith's turn to butcher a kick. He completes an amazing feat as he manages stuff up his goal kick so bad that the ball makes it all the way from one sideline to the other.
Isn't it great how the commentators talk him up before he kicks it?! In the same game, we move to extra time. Our first field goal attempt is added to the collection. Stacey Jones' addition is extra special: he was right in front, had plenty of time and... It would have won them the game!!!
A man with one leg could have knocked that one over! To Sunday, and a relatively new name in the league stuffed up this goal kick from nearly right in front.
Well done Josh Dugan. And finally our last edition for this massive weekend. Benji Marshall, who was instrumental in the Tigers comeback victory over the Knights, also managed to get himself a nomination. Take note of the great build up commentary by our friend Gus Gould.
Damnit Benji!
Anyway, that completes our collection from Round 7. In the end we think we may have chosen too many, so if you believe that any of those kicks aren't good (or bad) enough to be a final nomination, then you can cast a vote for that kick to be excluded in the poll located in the right column at the top (Go to the blog homepage if you are viewed this as a feed). Hopefully you can help us out there.
That wraps up last weekend horrible kicking showcase. We hope you enjoyed this special presentation of the Covell award and heres to there being more stuff ups in the weeks to come!
Labels:
Covell Award,
Footy,
NRL,
Rugby League,
Sport,
TC Ink
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)